Rivian CEO Criticizes EV Market for Copying Tesla’s Model Y

Rivian CEO and founder RJ Scaringe addressed the current state of the electric vehicle (EV) market and competition with Tesla in a recent interview with Nilay Patel, editor-in-chief of The Verge.

Scaringe emphasized the lack of choice in the sub-$50,000 EV market as a primary reason for the perceived slowdown in EV sales.

“What I would say is the primary reason for the slowdown is there is an extreme, truly extreme, lack of choice. If you want to spend less than $50,000 for an EV, I’d say there’s a very, very small number of great products,” Scaringe stated.

He acknowledged the strong market position of Tesla’s Model 3 and Model Y, noting that while they are highly compelling products, they face limited competition. Many competitors have created vehicles that closely resemble the Model Y in shape and size but fall short in performance.

Scaringe highlighted the saturation of Tesla vehicles in the market and the resultant customer flexibility regarding form factors. “Maybe they wanted a true SUV and got a very car-like crossover with the Model Y. Maybe they wanted something that was a little bit bigger, but they got something that was more like the Model Y. Maybe they didn’t love the Tesla look, but it’s the best product, so they took the Model Y,” he explained.

According to Scaringe, there is significant latent demand for EVs with diverse form factors and branding. He pointed to the positive reception of Rivian’s R2 model as evidence. The R2, designed not to replicate the Model Y, competes on price and size but offers a distinct alternative. “The R2 very intentionally, much like we did with R1, is not trying at all to be a Tesla Model Y. It’s going to compete from a price point of view, with very similar pricing. It’s a very similar size. It’s slightly shorter than a Model Y, but it’s not trying to replicate a Model Y,” Scaringe said.

While acknowledging the excellence of the Model Y, Scaringe stressed the need for variety in the market. “I think the world needs more variety. Our view is that there is — and to use your word, which I love the word — there is massive latent demand that’s sitting on the sidelines waiting for the vehicle that has the form factor, the packaging, the branding, the look, that will cause them to switch from a combustion-powered vehicle.”

There’s a reason carmakers are copying Tesla’s Model Y–it’s the world’s top-selling car. While automakers can copy the Model Y’s exterior and interior features, they can’t replicate Tesla’s software and Full Self-Driving advantages.